How to Use a Butt Plug: A Safe Beginner's Guide

How to Use a Butt Plug: A Safe Beginner's Guide

What is a Butt Plug?

A butt plug is a sex toy designed for anal pleasure. Its unique shape sets it apart from other anal toys like dildos and anal beads: it features a tapered tip for easy insertion, a wider body for fullness, and a flared base for safety.

Unlike dildos made for thrusting or beads for gradual movement, butt plugs are designed to be worn comfortably over time. This makes them particularly beginner-friendly.

The design creates a feeling of fullness that many find intensely pleasurable. During solo play, it can enhance masturbation. With a partner, it can intensify orgasms by stimulating internal nerve networks.

butt plug on hands

Why Try a Butt Plug?

The unique pleasure of a butt plug stems from the anus's high concentration of nerve endings, offering a deeply satisfying sense of fullness. This sensation is further enhanced as the plug can indirectly stimulate internal erogenous zones—such as the prostate or the internal clitoral network—through the anal wall, leading to intense orgasms. 

Its versatility serves multiple purposes: it can be a source of intense pleasure during solo or partnered play, act as a gentle warm-up to prepare for anal sex, or provide a constant state of low-key arousal when worn for extended periods.

Choosing the Right Butt Plug

Your butt plug should be designed for comfort and ease of use. Look for these features:

Size & Shape:

Start small. A beginner butt plug should be slender with a tapered tip. This makes insertion much easier. Avoid large or uniquely shaped plugs for your first time.

  • For Beginners: Opt for a plug with a width of about 1 inch (approximately 2.5 cm) or less to ensure a comfortable start.
  • For Intermediate Users: Once accustomed, you can explore mediums with more girth, typically around 1.5 inches at the widest point.
  • For Advanced Users: Those with experience may seek out larger butt plugs (exceeding 1.5 inches) or models with pronounced textures for heightened sensation.
butt plug size guide

Material:

Choose body-safe, non-porous materials like silicone, stainless steel, or glass. These are easy to clean and hypoallergenic. 

  • Silicone is a popular choice due to its softness and flexibility, offering great comfort. Note that it requires the use of water-based lubricants.
  • Stainless Steel provides a satisfying weight and is fantastic for temperature play. Its firmness offers a distinct sensation.
  • Glass is sleek, non-porous, and also great for temperature play, but its rigidity and fragility require careful use and storage.
materials of butt plug

Flared Base:

According to a study, Between 2012 and 2021, there were approximately 38,948 emergency department visits in the United States due to rectal foreign bodies, with the annual incidence rising from 1.2 to 1.9 cases per 100,000 people. Among these cases, 55.4% involved sexual devices.

This underscores the critical importance of a Flared Base: the base must be significantly wider than the insertable part to prevent the entire butt plug from being accidentally pulled into the rectum—a serious medical emergency. The anal sphincters are powerful muscles that contract rhythmically during pleasure, which can inadvertently draw objects inward. Unlike the vagina, the rectum has no end point, making a flared base an essential safety feature to prevent over-insertion and avoid such incidents.

butt plug flared base

Preparation is Key

A little prep goes a long way in ensuring a comfortable experience.

  • Personal Hygiene: It's perfectly normal to have concerns about cleanliness. While a plug only reaches the rectum (not the colon where stool is stored), it's true that bodies are complex and a small amount of residue can sometimes be present. A quick shower and external wash are usually all that's needed for peace of mind. For extra assurance, an anal douche can be used, but it's not mandatory. Keeping towels or wipes nearby is a practical precaution.
  • Toy Hygiene: Clean your butt plug thoroughly with warm water and a mild, antibacterial soap or a dedicated toy cleaner both before and after every use.
  • Your Environment: Find a private, comfortable space where you won't be rushed. Take a few deep breaths to relax your body and mind, as anxiety can tense your muscles.
  • Final Checks: Trim your fingernails to prevent any scratches or discomfort. Have your cleaned plug and a generous amount of lubricant within easy reach.

The Golden Rule of Anal Play: Lube, Lube, Lube!

The anus does not self-lubricate like the vagina. Using plenty of lubricant is essential for comfort and safety.

Apply a generous amount of lube to the tapered tip of the plug and along its shaft.

Don't forget to apply lube to your anus as well. You can use a finger to gently coat the entrance.

Reapply lube whenever things start to feel less than silky smooth.

apply lube to butt plug

A Step-by-Step Guide to Insertion

1.Get into a Comfortable Position

Lying on your side with one knee bent toward your chest, or squatting, are great positions that allow for easy access and relaxation. 

Consider trying:

  • Side-lying with knees tucked
  • Supported squatting
  • Leaning forward with hand support
  • Kneeling on all fours

2.Relax and Go Slow

Coat the entire butt plug surface and apply around your anal opening. Gently press the well-lubricated tip of the plug against your anus. Take slow, deep breaths and allow your muscles to relax.

3.Apply Gentle, Consistent Pressure

Don't force it. Let the plug enter at its own pace as your sphincter muscles relax and open. You might feel a slight "pop" as the widest part passes through the sphincter.

Discomfort might happen, but sharp pain is a sign to stop. Pause, apply more lube, and try again with slower, gentler pressure. If the pain persists, stop for the day.

spooning position to insert butt plug

Wearing and Enjoying Your Plug

Once the plug is correctly positioned with its base resting comfortably against your skin, you can begin to explore the sensations. For your first time, we recommend wearing it for no more than 15-20 minutes to allow your body to adjust.

Listening to Your Body

It's completely normal to feel an urge to push the plug out as your muscles adjust to the new sensation. This is your body's natural response. If at any point you feel significant discomfort, gently remove the plug. As you grow more comfortable, you can gradually extend your wearing time.

Exploring New Dimensions of Pleasure

  • Solo Play: Many users find that wearing a butt plug during masturbation creates more intense sensations, particularly during orgasm.
  • With Partner: During vaginal intercourse or other forms of partnered sexual activity, the plug can enhance pleasure for all involved through added internal pressure.
  • Creating Combinations: Consider pairing your plug with other toys or incorporating it into different sexual scenarios to discover what feels best for you.
diagram of anal plug insertion

Aftercare Guide

Safe Removal

Removal is typically easier than insertion, but should still be done with care and patience:

  • Relax and Breathe: As during insertion, take deep breaths to help your muscles relax.
  • Go Slow: Never yank the plug. Hold the flared base and pull it out slowly and steadily. You may find that a gentle wiggling or twisting motion helps ease it out comfortably.
  • Cleanup Note: A small amount of lubricant or natural fluid on the butt plug after removal is completely normal.

Essential Aftercare

Your body has just had a new experience—be kind to it.

  • Care for Your Body: It's common to feel some sensitivity or tenderness afterward. A warm shower, using a soft cloth, staying hydrated, and resting in something comfortable can help you recover.
  • Clean Your Toy: Wash your butt plug thoroughly with warm water and mild antibacterial soap or a dedicated toy cleaner immediately after use.
  • Proper Storage: Ensure the plug is completely dry, then store it in its original storage bag or a clean, dry place to protect it from dust, lint, and damage.
how to properly store an anal plug

Exploring anal play with a butt plug can open up a new world of pleasure. The keys to a great experience are patience, plenty of lubricant, and a commitment to listening to your body. Start small, go slow, and enjoy the journey of discovery. Happy exploring!